Galpin Society logo

The Galpin Society

The American Musical Instrument Society

AMIS Logo

CONFERENCE ON MUSICAL INSTRUMENTS

Oxford - London - Edinburgh

3 - 9 AUGUST 2003

ABSTRACTS OF PAPERS

URL: http://www.euchmi.ed.ac.uk/gxkta.html

See also the Conference Programme

See also the Schedule of Papers Sessions

Conference administration: Edinburgh University Collection of Historic Musical Instruments

e-mail: euchmi@ed.ac.uk

The 17th century - Non-Destructive Analysis of Early English "Brass" Trumpets By X-Ray Fluorescence

Louise Bacon,
Head Collections Conservation & Care
The Horniman Museum
London

As a part of the author's PhD thesis, the metal composition of most of the surviving English inscribed trumpets from the seventeenth century have been analysed by x-ray fluorescence. These include trumpets by Augustine Dudley, William Bull and John Harris. The results show that the trumpets were not made of brass, but mainly of a copper/tin/zinc alloy. This ternary alloy can be identified in contemporary accounts as latten, and in the present day as gunmetal. Research into the technology and history, and source of copper alloys can help to understand why brass was probably not used as a material. There are very few surviving musical instruments from this period to indicate a trend, but it may be possible to postulate an English tradition of making trumpets in this fashion. This was perhaps only superseded in the early eighteenth century by the influx of German musical instrument makers, bringing with them the tradition of making instruments in brass, coinciding with the revival of the brass industry in England.

The Kanun: Traditional and Modern Turkish Style Structure, Construction, Education System and Performance Techniques

S. Sehvar Besiroglu
Musicology Department, State Conservatory, Istanbul Technical University, Turkey

  1. The history of the kanun (Mughal and Ottoman courts as depicted in contemporary paintings). Psalteries, which were used as early as Babylonians and Asryians were stringed instruments, played with fingers, plectrums or hammers. Through Arabian Peninsula these instruments traveled to West Africa and Andalusia finally reaching Europe and assuming names Salterio (played with a plectrum) and Dulcimer (played with hammers). After a series of developments these instruments finally become cembalo and piano respectively. Another instrument historically related to the psaltery is the Middle Eastern kanun. Its name first appeared in a 10th century version of Arabian Nights. Farabi, who lived in the 10th century, gave a detailed histography of this instrument and present form was first developed by him. In the 13th century Al Salahi gave a description of this instrument as "this instrument has 50-60 strings, crossing over a bridge and its name is in the Persian language". Also in 13th century Safiyüddin Abdülmümin Urmevi describes the same instrument under the name of "Nüzhe". 13th and 14th century Andalusian sources refer to this instrument as the most popular instrument of the time. In Ottoman history it was recorded that in the court of Mehmet the Conqueror there was a kanun player by the name of Ishak. The kanun was known to Turks as early as the 15th century.
  2. The Structure and construction of the kanun in Turkey during 20th century
  3. Education system. The traditional education system during the Ottoman Empire called Mesk (Oral Traditions) and changes during the westernisation and modernisation period after the 19th century.
  4. Performance techniques of kanun in Turkey traditional and modern style. In discussing Turkish style kanun and performance in the sense of instrumentation and orchestration, terms related to traditional playing and terms that have a place in global music literature are also mentioned; in addition to its tuning system, its compass, its characteristic tessitura, and playing techniques. The instrumentation in works prepared for harp (which is used in modern music and has certain similarities with kanun ) are analysed in a detailed way. New playing techniques using the fingers.
  5. Suggestions for the adaptation of the notation of traditional Turkish style kanun playing techniques as well as advanced kanun playing are offered.

    Retelling the Story of the British Museum Gittern

    Kate Buehler
    St. Paul, Minnesota, U.S.A.

    The British Museum Gittern is a peerless musical treasure. It is the only extant medieval citole, and the oldest English stringed instrument to survive nearly intact. From its exquisite carvings, to its tantalizing silverwork bearing the crests of Queen Elizabeth I and Robert Dudley, to its battered eighteenth century soundboard, the gittern presents a fascinating story.

    The goal of this paper is to retell that story as completely as possible by establishing a context for its creation and following the trail of its subsequent ownership. The telling is based on organological arguments stemming from an examination of the gittern itself, on historical research involving people and places with which the gittern interacted, and social considerations which suggest how it was regarded and used in each setting. Hitherto unnoticed evidence on the instrument reveals that it went through three distinct orientations as a functional musical instrument: a medieval citole, an Elizabethan violin, and an eighteenth century violin.

    The gittern has long been accepted to date from the early fourteenth century. I propose that the original construction of the gittern took place in East Anglia between 1310 and 1320. The style of the carvings on the gittern strongly suggest that the carver was a native to the East Anglian Decorated style. This tie is strengthened upon consideration of citoles portrayed in East Anglian artwork from this same period. The high quality of the workmanship suggests aristocratic patronage, and Edward II is a likely candidate.

    The most tantalizing chapter in the gittern’s history is suggested by the silver peg box cover bearing the crests of Elizabeth I and Robert Dudley, and a silver pin stamped with the date 1578. Using organological evidence in addition to social and historical considerations, I affirm that this silverwork is authentic, and that the gittern was transformed into a violin for Elizabeth by Dudley.

    The gittern was modernized yet again in the eighteenth century, probably while it was owned by the Dukes of Dorset. It was sold in auction around 1769, and for approximately forty years circulated on the London market, finally being purchased by the Warwick family sometime before 1806. Restorative and preservative work in the mid-nineteenth century resulted in an electrotype copy owned by the Victoria and Albert Museum. The gittern has ultimately come to the British Museum, where it hints to thousands of admirers of the stories of its 700-year life.

    Nicks, Kerfs, and Joints: the Story of the Cornett, 1750-1850, as Revealed in Documents and Instruments

    Stewart Carter,
    Wake Forest University, U.S.A.

    After reaching the zenith of its popularity in the early decades of the seventeenth century, when composers such as Claudio Monteverdi and Biagio Marini wrote virtuoso parts for it, the cornett entered a long, slow decline. My study demonstrates the continued use of the cornett as late as the 1840s, almost exclusively in German-speaking areas. Evidence for the instrument's survival comes from documents, principally in the form of treatises on instrumentation, as well as twelve instruments that survive in collections in Europe and the United States.

    Surviving treatises demonstrate that many nineteenth-century writers were familiar with the cornett. Some French authors, such as Berlioz, betray fundamental misunderstandings of the instrument, while German and Austrian writers had more first-hand knowledge of it. Franz-Xaver Glöggl's Kirchenmusik Ordnung (1828) demonstrates the continued use of the cornett in the churches of Linz. Jean-Georges Kastner's Supplément au Traité général d'instrumentation (1844) contains an eyewitness account of the instrument's use. Kastner's treatise is in French, but his report concerns a performance he heard in Stuttgart.

    A study of surviving instruments reveals that construction techniques evolved as the popularity of the cornett waned. Cornetts were by this time largely a sideline for makers, who in some cases adapted techniques used in making other woodwinds to the manufacture of cornetts. Seven of the surviving cornetts from this late period represent a new form of the instrument, the three-piece straight variety, its articulated construction apparently inspired by contemporary flutes and oboes. For the manufacture of curved cornetts, makers adapted techniques used in the construction of such woodwinds as the oboe di caccia and the curved type of English horn and basset horn: X-ray photographs of a curved cornett from 1805 reveal how the instrument was "kerfed" or nicked in order facilitate bending with steam.

    Surviving instruments further confirm Germany as the locus for the instrument in this late period. All six of the late cornetts that bear signatures were made in Germany, and five of these were made either in the instrument-making village of Neukirchen or within a radius of sixty kilometers.

    Making a National Collection for a National Instrument: Bagpipes in the National Museums of Scotland

    Hugh Cheape
    National Museums of Scotland
    Edinburgh

    The bagpipe has often and popularly been perceived as Scotland's "national" instrument but has been variously, often poorly, represented in national historical, ethnological and musicological collections. It has tended to fall below the gaze of musicological scholarship until the recent work of Baines and Cannon, and seems to have been a poor relation in musical instrument history, paradoxically perhaps given its pedigree and its technical and tonal characteristics. Where examples of bagpipes have been collected into museums, they have in the past been acquired for their association with person or event (often the factor ensuring their survivial), or for their craftsmanship and aesthetic qualities for display in museums of decorative arts.

    The need for some curatorial expertise in the field of traditional music in the National Museum of Antiquities of Scotland, given a growing volume of demand for information in the late-twentieth century, and a proposal in 1976 for a Festival Exhibition in this subject area highlighted gaps and obvious shortfalls in the collections of Scotland's national instrument. An acquisition policy was formulated in 1978-79 to fill some of these gaps and to study the history and the material culture of the bagpipe in Scotland in a more deliberate and systematic fashion. In the near-quarter century of the application of this policy, a relatively large and representative collection of Scottish, British and European bagpipes has been brought together in the National Museums of Scotland (themselves the creation of the National Heritage [Scotland] Act of 1985), and important collaborative initiatives developed with the Edinburgh Universitiy Collection of Historic Musical Instruments (since 1983) and the National Piping Centre in Glasgow (since 1995).

    This paper give a detailed account of the piping collections of the National Museums of Scotland and of the exercise of this collecting policy, as well as new research and perspectives for ethnomusicology, to suggest that a collection of national and international significance has now been created for Scotland.

    An Unusual 18th-century Upright Piano by the Edinburgh-based maker, Richard Horsburgh

    John Cranmer,
    Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama, Cardiff

    This paper considers an unusual, 18th-century Upright Piano by the Edinburgh-based maker, Richard Horsburgh (supposedly invented by the celebrated Italian singer and teacher, Domenico Corri) only one of which appears to be extant. The first part of the paper will place the instrument within the context of Horsburgh's work, whilst the second considers its unusual intended use and its likely usefulness.

    Transitions in American Snare Drums

    Jayson Dobney,
    Vermillion

    American snare, or side, drums changed drastically between the American Civil War and World War I. American manufacturers were influenced by many ideas from Europe, but they were much slower at adopting technological advances, such as metal tension rods and separate-tensioning. This paper will piece together, for the first time, the major innovations and contributions made by various American manufacturers, as well as European influences. Surviving drums, patents, and trade catalogs will all be used to document these changes in American snare drums.

    Metal tensioning rods were first patented by Englishman Cornelius Ward in 1837. By the 1840s and 50s, other European drum makers were producing snare drums utilizing his ideas, or experimenting with their own tension devices. Very few of these drums seem to have been imported to America, which continued to use rope-tension instruments throughout the American Civil War and beyond. Banjo makers, both in England and America, did utilize metal tension rods as early as the 1840s. Ironically, many of the banjo makers, such as William Esperance Boucher, Jr., of Baltimore, were also drum makers, but they did not apply the same technology to drums. It was not until "Prussian drums" became available in catalogs by John F. Stratton, H.C. Barnes, and C.G. Conn in the 1870s and 80s that rod tension drums were widely available to American drummers.

    American patents in the nineteenth century show that there was much experimentation in separate-tensioning, including patents from as early as the 1860s. It would not be until 1882 that Emile Boulanger of St. Louis would offer the first commercially successful separate- tension-rod snare drum in America. Still, American drums continued to be primarily either rope-tensioned or simple, single-tension rod drums typified by instruments produced by the Leedy firm of Indianapolis, Indiana, one of the largest drum manufacturers in the country, well into the twentieth century.

    William F. Ludwig was so impressed by a German separate-tension rod drum that he acquired, that he tried to convince Leedy to make similar drums. After Leedy refused, Ludwig, along with his brother Theobald, started making their own drums, based on the German design, in Chicago. These drums were the first "modern" drums offered in America. By the mid-1920s Ludwig and Ludwig had grown in to the largest drum company in the world, and practically every American drum maker was producing separate-tension rod drums.

    The Piccolo: a Study of its History and Development

    Danielle Eden
    Sydney, Australia

    Prior to this study, little information had been collated about the piccolo: earlier texts suggested a development identical to the flute, with no apparent differentiation between the two. However, these instruments although similar to each other, did not routinely follow each other's progression. Their history and their usage does contain differences not formerly presented in detail.

    This presentation is concerned with tracing the instrumental development of the piccolo from its initial production to the application of the Boehm system and alternatives, concentrating on the period since 1800, which required cohesive documentation. Patent specifications and their application to the piccolo will be discussed. Extant instruments presented include examples from collections not previously catalogued or displayed.

    Finishing Touches: The British Role in the Origin of the Modern Cornet

    Niles Eldredge,
    The American Museum of Natural History
    New York

    As is well-known, the soprano brasswind cornet à pistons is a quintessentially French invention. By the early 1850s, Parisian makers began to favor the Périnet valve over the older Stölzel valve, and to produce, longer, less deeply cornopean-shaped instruments.

    The next wave of innovation in cornet design reflects a decidedly British influence. Until the mid-1850s, the bells of all cornet à pistons, regardless of valve type, remained on the right side of the instrument. Though it was the Parisian maker A. Courtois who apparently was the first to place the bell on the left, it is clear that the instant popularity of this "reversed bell" (or "modèle anglais") in Britain, was the main impetus behind the eventual adoption of this form in virtually all cornets.

    British manufacturers began making "reversed bell" instruments by the late 1860s, and the origin of the modern form of the Périnet valve seems to be closely correlated with these early efforts. The oldest known surviving Besson (London) reversed bell cornet is a single waterkey instrument with what has remained the modern "wrap" of the leadpipe-but with an experimental valve that is not quite in the modern configuration. This instrument is identical in all other respects to their slightly later Desideratum model-the oldest known essentially modern cornet, in production certainly by 1869, and with what has long since become the modern version of the Périnet valve.

    Meanwhile Distin & Co. were selling, also by ca. 1869, their double waterkey modèle anglais Courtois copy-but with a valve design very similar to that of the Besson Desideratum. No known patents of this, the modern valve, have yet come to light-leaving to speculation at this point whether Besson and Distin & Co. independently and simultaneously came up with the modern Périnet valve, or (more likely) one maker copied the unpatented valve from the other. Based on documented Besson patents of earlier designs, it is arguably more likely that it was Besson, rather than Distin & Co., who first produced Périnet valves of the modern design. Both makers were clearly intent on capturing some of the British market share from the highly successful Courtois modèle anglais cornets that had become so popular over the preceding decade.

    Rhodolph Hall: Nineteenth-Century American Keyed Bugle, Cornet and Clarinet Soloist

    Robert Eliason,
    Lyme, New Hampshire

    Rhodolph Hall was one of the most successful of American band soloists in the middle years of the 1800s. He is known to have played flute, clarinet, keyed bugle, cornet, ebor corno (a valved alto brass instrument), trombone, violin, and even some penny whistle. He played with town and military bands, dance bands, circuses, minstrel shows, bell ringers, and other concert ensembles, and toured widely, including trips throughout the eastern and mid-western states, California, Cuba, Canada, and England. His career touched on the change in the United States from mixed woodwind and brass bands to bands of all brass by the 1840s. It also documents the change there from the keyed bugle as the principal solo brass instrument to the cornet. His letters show that American brass bands formed in the 1840s and 1850s were sometimes well-paid professional organizations and that wind soloists were popular and well rewarded. Early in his career he was presented with a fine, silver keyed bugle made by E.G. Wright, Boston, and later an exquisite solid gold cornet made by Hall & Quinby, Boston. A unique feature of his performance was a cornet with an echo attachment first used with telling effect on his tour of England in 1861. This paper will examine his career as a soloist, the instruments he played, his travels, and the rewards he earned.

    Henry John Distin (1819-1903): A Centenary Critical Evaluation: Was he the Very Model of a Major Manufacturer ?

    Lloyd P. Farrar,
    Norris, Tennessee, U.S.A.

    Arnold Myers
    University of Edinburgh

    Was he the very model of a major manufacturer ?
    This talk attempts to tell some very, very pretty facts that are
    related to his cornets, tenors, basses, and euphonions
    that are found in museums from London to Smithsonian !

    Henry Distin was English-born, but he died in Philadelphia in October one century ago. In his latter-day career in his adopted country he was styled in the press as "The last of the great Cornet Makers" (referring directly to Besson and Courtois as those who preceded him). Yet in a statement circulated widely by a competitor, a former Distin employee and associate asserted that Distin knew very well how to judge a good cornet but did not himself know how to make one. Between these two hyperbolic extremes may be found the true importance of a flamboyant personality who indeed influenced greatly the world of instrument manufacture, also the popularity of the then-new piston valve brasswinds and the explosive growth of brass bands during his lifetime.

    Distin was the principal proprietor of Distin & Sons, dealers and manufacturers in London after ca. 1850 until the enterprise known as Distin & Co became the manufactory for Boosey & Co. Extant shop records with Boosey & Hawkes show the compartmentalization of the various components of brasswinds into crafts departments with eventual assembly and marketing through other departments; i.e., an application of a method of industrial large-scale production that Distin may have learned from his experience with established French makers, especially Guichard and his successors, where similar factory organization already was successfully in place.

    Distin introduced like in-house departments in America where, drawing on his established reputation both as a player and a maker, he established in New York City, Philadelphia and environs and eventually in Williamsport, Pennsylvania large factories with steam-driven machinery and large workforces using several tools and techniques patented by Distin in America. Distin's brasswinds were widely advertised in trade journals and house advertizing periodicals under trade names such as "SUPERIOR", "HIGHEST GRADE", and "CELEBRATED" to an extent and to an effectiveness previously unknown in the industry there or in Europe. This aspect - the utilization of mass publications and the press to drive sales of a factory-produced line of instruments - possibly was the single most innovative contribution made by Distin.

    Archival documents preserved in England and in many American cities, surviving trade publications and newspapers as well as numerous extant instruments bearing dual serial numbers (bell and valves) as well as an effusive trademark certification provide more detail about his life and methods of industrial organization than perhaps is found for any of his contemporaries among instrument makers. He emerges as a man who sensed the energy of the rising industrialization of all the old crafts - textiles, furniture, tool making, metals technology - and utilized this energy to found a series of industrial enterprises that left him at the end of his life able to retire respected as a great manufacturer of musical instruments. He lived out the closing thirteen years of his life sustained by this earned reputation and on a pension for himself and his family by the company that bore his name, HENRY DISTIN MFG CO. A number of tools patented under his name and several truly excellent patterns for instrument design also patented were uniquely brilliant inventions credited to him, even though it is probable that the technology of these may always have been achieved through the skills of his employees in London, New York, and Pennsylvania. He began his career as a horn player in a family concert quintet, but he ended his life as a famous industrial innovator. Much of what he did was idiomatic to the spirit of the age in which he lived, but also his manner of work made much of what he did appear fresh, exciting, and largely unique to the Distin persona.

    Another Juggler: Instruments and Instrumentalists in Early Modern Oxford

    Michael Fleming,
    Oxford

    "There is another Iugler, that beeing well skild in the Iewes Trumpe, takes vpon him to bee a dealer in Musicke: especiall good at mending Instruments: he iugled away more instrumentes of late, than his bodie (being taken) will euer be able to make good." - Henry Chettle, Kind-Hartes Dreame, (1592).

    Over the last few years, documentary evidence from the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries has provided increasing amounts of information about instrument-making in English cities other than London and has assisted those who seek a more accurate understanding of provincial music. Building on previous work about inhabitants of Oxford and York, new research into the people involved in musical activities in Oxford will now be presented and discussed. This will focus on people who made musical instruments, but will also include information about professional and amateur instrumentalists, and about some of the relationships between all these and other musicians and woodworkers. Some common sources of confusion in research about instrument-makers will be described and exemplified.

    The information to be presented will support earlier findings about the nature of instrument-makers, particularly that for many, instrument making was only part of their work, so instruments were often made not by specialist instrument-makers but by people who may be better known for other activities. This raises important questions, such as how did English instruments attain their high international reputation ? The work also casts new light on some important names in the string instrument making world. There are indications that relatively obscure Oxford instrument-makers are connected with some better-known makers in London. It is possible that far from being backward, derivative or even parasitic in relation to London, centres such as Oxford provided not only the manpower but possibly also the foundation or driving force for significant developments in other parts of the country, including the capital.

    Tinctoris's Imperfect Dulcina Perfected - the Mary Rose Still Shawm

    Charles Foster,
    Aberdeen

    In 1980 a shawm was recovered from Henry VIII's flagship, the Mary Rose. In the January 1983 issue of Early Music, Frances Palmer gives a description of this instrument, along with architectural drawings of it. The unusual nature of this instrument, with its narrow cylindrical bore and addition of a thumbhole, prompted Herbert W. Myers to contribute an article to the July 1983 issue of Early Music. Here he argues very convincingly that the Mary Rose instrument was not a normal conically-bored shawm, but the sole example of a cylindrically-bored shawm, dulcina or douE7aine or still shawm to have survived from the Renaissance. This theory could not be proved conclusively, owing to the incomplete measurements supplied in Early Music, and no additional information was forthcoming. It was not until April 1996, after much speculation had arisen as to the nature and condition of the shawm, that I was allowed to examine the instrument at Portsmouth. Shortly afterwards, I was invited to make a detailed study of all the wind instruments recovered from the Mary Rose, to write a detailed account of them, to make playing replicas of them, and to make recordings of them playing individually, and as a band playing along with replicas of the fiddles also recovered.

    This presentation will give a detailed description of the construction and nature of the instrument with its unique fingering system, employing the little fingers of both hands. Demonstrations from a replica will confirm Herbert Myers' speculation that this instrument is indeed a narrow cylindrically-bored bass instrument, designed to be overblown at the 12th, with its unique fingering system enabling the notes between the two registers to be sounded. Whereas Tinctoris' dulcina, which he describes as imperfect, has a range of only a 9th, the Mary Rose shawm has been perfected, with a complete range of an octave and a 6th, plus one low note a 4th below, enabling it to play virtually any bass line in Tudor Music. No records appear to exist describing any instrument which can overblow in this manner, until the invention of the clarinet. This presentation will also illustrate, on slides, possible still shawms, and shawms playing in the company of pipe and tabor, and fiddle. Recordings of a band using the above instruments, from copies made from instruments recovered from the Mary Rose, will also be played.

    Frédéric Triebert (1813-1878), Designer of the Modern Oboe: Newly Found Archival Documents Featuring the Inventory and Auction of his Musical Instrument Enterprise

    Tula Giannini,
    Pratt Institute

    Frédéric Triebert was the dominant figure in oboe making in France for almost 40 years, 1842-1878; the oboe he designed and manufactured defines the modern oboe. This paper presents newly found documents from the Archives Nationales (Minutier Central, AJ 13-Opéra, and AJ 37-Conservatoire) and Archives de Paris which reveal for the first time in great detail the Triebert instrument enterprise and workshop, his German origins and family ties with prominent French makers. They shed new light on his family relationships and unconventional personal life as inseparable from his musical life while inscribing a social milieu defined by friends, customers, marriage, his mistress-reed maker, business partnerships and successors. From 1842, his name appears on the annual list of official suppliers of instruments to the Paris Opera and Conservatory ensuring that his instruments were played by leading artists of the capital. Invoices confirm his thriving business as a publisher of oboe music and maker of reeds and accessories. He was equally influential for the bassoon. Collaborating with Theobald Boehm, he designed and produced the first Boehm system bassoon. His protégé, François Lorée, established the Lorée firm and maker's mark which is found today on oboes played by professionals worldwide. Instruments by Triebert are today cherished possessions of museums, collectors and performers. Their diverse key systems display his remarkable ingenuity for design, also evident in his patents. He developed the modern oboe as not only an instrument of immense technical capabilities, but also as one which succeeds equally in capturing the oboe's Gallic authenticity and characteristic orchestral sound.

    Towards a Taxonomy of Piano Actions

    Edwin M. Good,
    Smithsonian Institution,
    Washington, D.C.

    Perhaps the most influential classification of actions is the German distinction between Stoßmechanik and Prellmechanik, which Walter Pfeiffer’s translator called "Pushing" and "Bumping" actions. Pfeiffer added two more: "Pulling" (Zug) and "Linked" (Gelenk). These and other classification schemes start from the ways in which hammers are activated, as does a more complex mode of description proposed by Michael Cole.

    I wish to start further back. The piano action solves a particular mechanical problem: to propel the hammer to the string (and away from it) with speed that determines the volume of sound produced and is proportional to the weight or speed of the player’s finger on the key. The solution is by the means of leverage. I will proceed from the kinds of levers used and the ways they work to solve the piano’s problem.

    Working from the three types of levers, I examine first the hammer assemblies as levers, then the ways in which keys are connected mechanically with hammer assemblies, whether operating directly on them or with intermediate levers. I look at the kinds of leverage provided by intermediate levers. And I investigate the ways levers move hammers in the three directions that pianos have required: upwards, downwards, and horizontally.

    These issues form the taxonomical structure. I will discuss and illustrate the types and sub-types with action diagrams.

    Musical instrument making at St Paul's Churchyard, 1660-1725

    Ben Hebbert
    St Cross College, University of Oxford,
    Oxford, U.K.

    St Paul's Churchyard is synonymous with the music trade in London from the manufacture of the earliest music books printed in England up until the nineteenth century. As a centre for the manufacture and sale of musical instruments, this area began to develop after the Restoration of King Charles II in 1660, and during the 1680s became a primary focus of the English trade.

    Based on recent research into the Seventeenth century music trade, and including new information uncovered during the course of my doctoral study (The English Music Trade, c.1647-1725), this paper will illustrate the influences that fuelled the emergence of this group of makers, its demise less than fifty years later. Casting light on many celebrated figures such as Nathaniel Cross, Barak Norman and Richard Hunt, and also the cloudier figures of Robert Hubert (alias Forges) or the enigmatic Daniel Parker, this study will examine the social context in which different tiers of instrument makers lived.

    Harry Edward Freund and His Great Square-Piano Bonfire

    William E. Hettrick
    Hofstra University
    Hempstead, New York

    History's most notorious incident of wholesale destruction of musical instruments was the purposeful burning of a large number of old square pianos at Atlantic City, New Jersey, on the evening of May 24, 1904. The conflagration was planned to coincide with the joint meeting of the National Association of Piano Dealers of America and the National Piano Manufacturers' Association of America, although it was not part of the official program. The event was entirely the creation of Harry Edward Freund, the ambitious editor of The Musical Age, a New York trade journal aimed chiefly at piano dealers. Among the many concerns that Freund raised in his weekly periodical, none seems to have fired (!) his enthusiasm and imagination as much as the claim that dealers were suffering losses by having to give trade-in allowances on their old, outmoded square pianos. His solution to the problem was to stage a public demonstration of the worthlessness of the squares in a way that would generate maximum publicity.

    Freund's campaign began in The Musical Age on November 7, 1903, with his editorial "Burn the Old Squares at the Atlantic City Convention." Subsequent issues presented further inducements supported by letters of approval and reprints of newspaper articles from all over the country. Freund made sure that his name was mentioned at every opportunity, and that the bonfire ceremony during the convention was described in detail, especially the point at which he set his torch to the pile of kerosene-soaked pianos, reported to number one thousand. The event, of course, was deemed a triumph, but Freund's plan was not yet fully realized, for he continued to feature reports on "The Passing of the Old Square Piano" in The Musical Age. The issue of December 17, 1904, delivered his final salvo: a barrage of 281 articles, some rather colorful, culled from newspapers in 133 cities of the United States and Canada.

    This paper will trace the full history of Freund's Great Bonfire from its inception to its final outcome, drawing on documentary evidence from a number of sources. Freund's influence, as a leading member of the musical trade press, on the retail piano business of his time will be evaluated. The presentation will also consider opposing views of his plan of destruction and its significance, including claims made by his journalistic competitors that the whole thing was a hoax!

    Stradivari's Viols

    Myrna Herzog,
    Bar Ilan University
    Israel

    This paper gives an overall view of all we know presently of Stradivari's output of viols, including a historical background, the extant instruments, the instruments we know of through different sources, and a study of the patterns.

    Acoustical concepts in early string instrument-making

    Herbert Heyde,
    Metropolitan Museum of Art
    New York

    Before physical acoustics gained ground and influenced thinking and methods of instrument makers, makers used among others artistic concepts to design beautifully toned instruments. Gradually physical concepts crept into the makers' approaches. The paper speaks about an empirical attempt to identify concepts in 16-18th century string instrument making that have both an artistic and a physical character. The paper also discusses the issue of causality regarding the different design methods.

    Two Late Renaissance Clavichords

    Lewis Jones,
    London Metropolitan University

    Alicja Knast
    Adam Mickiewicz University, Poznan, Poland

    Two relatively little-known clavichords are described and compared. That at the St. Clara Convent, Stary Sacz, Poland (now known there as virginal) is an apparently unique surviving example of the kind of instrument in which the entire soundboard is below the level of the key levers. Like those of the fifteenth century, it has a single, straight bridge. An inscription on the lid pays homage to an early seventeenth-century abbesses of the convent. The instrument seems to be part of the dowry which she brought to the convent on leaving the secular world, for her personal use. Along with a sixteenth century chamber organ and organa preserved in the binding of a liturgical volume there, it bears witness to the importance of music in the convent. The strict rules of the convent, difficulty of access, and isolation from the many wars fought on Polish territory contribute to the remarkable state of preservation of the instrument. A hexagonal clavichord of Italianate construction in the Musée de la Musique, Paris, resembles that by Dominicus Pisaurensis (whose name it misleadingly bears) in Leipzig, and also the clavichord of Italianischer mensur shown by Praetorius (whose compass it shares), with a stepped and sloping soundboard intended for multiple bridges. In contrast to the Stary Sacz instrument, that in Paris has undergone several changes. Its accretions are identified and its probable original state reconstructed. The scalings, fretting patterns and other musical properties of the instruments are compared.

    Gautrot's Valve Improvements

    Bruno Kampmann,
    Paris

    The Gautrot firm was the first in France to develop mass production. If Adolphe Sax's inventions are now well known, Gautrot's improvements are now forgotten, due to their lack of success at this time. However some ideas, as the compensating valves, came perhaps too early, because they obtained a great success when they were rediscovered several years after by Blaikley for the Boosey company.

    Some important valve improvements will be explained during this lecture: the Stoelzel valve with lateral port, the cor omnitonique, and the different patents on the système équitonique.

    William Lander (1763-1843) of Mere/Wiltshire and His Activities in Musical Instrument Making

    Sabine Klaus,
    America's National Music Museum,
    Landrum, South Carolina, U.S.A.

    The entry concerning a certain "Lander" in the New Langwill Index is very brief. It contains nothing but a two line statement: "Lander Brass Instruments, flourishing Mere/Wiltshire  ?mid 19c. LOCATION metal serpent reported: (Sotheby's 1950)" (William Waterhouse: The New Langwill Index, London 1993, p. 223)

    This serpent is most likely the one, which is now part of the Joe & Joella Utley Collection of Brass Instruments at America's National Music Museum. It is a rather unusual instrument of copper with flaring bell. In the attempt to find out more about its maker, who is otherwise unknown in the musical instrument field, I wrote to the archives in Mere in Wiltshire. This triggered an amazing discovery: There is a lot known about this person due to the research of a descendant of his, Ronald Bristow of Maidstone, Kent. The bulk of this knowledge comes from two handwritten notebooks of William Lander's in private possession. And - as one would wish - these notebooks confirm that Lander, who was a trained brazier, was concerned with the manufacture of brass instruments among other musical instruments and many technical inventions as well as every day items.

    These notebooks give fascinating insights into the construction of the instruments built by Lander, the proportions behind them, how they were soldered or varnished, and which materials were used. Besides brass instruments, which were obviously Lander's main field of musical activity, a recipe for violin varnish and the construction of a harmonica are described. Also, some comments about other English instrument makers are found.

    In my lecture I will give a short biography of William Lander, and discuss several of the entries on musical instruments in his notebooks, which are a new discovery in our field. Also, Lander's appearantly only surviving instrument, the copper serpent in the Utley Collection, will be subject of my lecture. I will attempt to shine light onto a talented musical instrument maker, working in a small, remote village in England, who was therefore forgotten over the centuries. In this respect, Lander might be represenative for many others yet to be discovered.

    Consorts of Musettes in 17th-Century France

    James B. Kopp
    Hoboken, NJ, U.S.A.

    Bagpipes, bagpipe chanters, and other mouth-blown, double-reed instruments were combined in varied ensembles in 17th-century France, the most conspicuous being the Hautbois et musettes de Poitou, a division of the royal musical establishment. In this paper I will survey evidence of instrumental types, players, repertory and terminological issues, including the following:
    1. A report from Basse-Marche (a province bordering Poitou) documented circa 1630 that untutored laborers and peasants played branles in four parts upon their hautbois et cornemuses, "without tablature or other aid".
    2. Marin Mersenne (1636) made no reference to a musette de Poitou, although he pictured and described a quartet comprised of the conically bored cornemuse and three sizes of hautbois de Poitou: dessus (a detached chanter of the cornemuse), taille and basse.

      Personnel records from 1625-61, however, help to identify the missing musette. On occasions when the cornemuse player used a windcap instead of the bag, his chanter was called dessus de musette de Poitou. The bass instrument was also played with a windcap (basse de musette de Poitou). One dessus chanter and the taille were normally played with the bare reed taken into the mouth, being called dessus (or taille) de hautbois de Poitou.

    3. Two famed members of the Hautbois et musettes de Poitou apparently commuted between sharply contrasting fingering systems. Jean Destouches (active 1620-38) and Jean Hotteterre (active 1650-66) played hautbois de Poitou in the royal quartet, presumably using conically bored instruments with an "open" or oboe-like fingering system. Yet both men were also noted as players of the bellows-blown, cylindrically bored musette de cour, which used a "closed" system, opening only one finger at a time.
    4. Mersenne reported that four, five or more cylindrical bagpipe chanters (chalumeaux ordinaires, in different sizes) were played in French consorts.
    5. Pierre Borjon de Scellery (1672) raised the possibility of combining two or more musettes in consorts with other woodwinds; context suggests that he was referring to bag-blown musettes de cour with extended ranges. Mersenne also mentioned that certain double-reed, conical instruments played the bass part in "consorts of musettes and voices".
    6. The "Mémoire sur les musettes", written circa 1740 by the court flutist Michel de la Barre, should be understood as an obituary for the musette de Poitou, which fell from favor under Lully and Louis XIV circa 1661. The musette de cour, favored by both these absolutists, continued to enjoy popularity until the 1740s.

    Engoma (Drums): The Heart of A Culture in East Africa

    James K. Makubuya,
    Wabash College, USA

    The focus of this paper presentation is to examine the meaning and significance of a category of musical instruments in their traditional cultural setting within an East African country. Specifically the paper discusses the research findings on the function, meaning and significance of musical instruments referred to as ehoma (drums) in the traditional setting of the culture of the Baganda, a people that originate in the East African nation of Uganda.

    In my most recent research, I was fascinated by the discovery that from time immemorial, the culture of the Baganda has been known to have put the ehoma to a multitude of uses; and that despite recent modifications in the Baganda's life styles as a result of modernity, the ehoma continue to have a place not only in the major royal palace functions and events but also in the most solemn, and joyous cultural ceremonies, rites and rituals of the commoners, as well as in such other identifying and unifying cultural events. Prior to discussing the musical and contextual functions of the ehoma, the paper will start with a brief look at the structural design of the ehoma as artifacts of the Baganda; specifically the paper will highlight the fact that regardless of whether they are used by the royalty or the commoners, the ehoma are made in only two basic shapes: the cone-shaped and the cylindrical ones.

    After discussing the musical roles and functions illustrated by audio and video clips from traditional ensembles, the paper will examine and discuss other non-musical roles the Baganda assign the various ehoma types. The non musical functions to be discussed as performed by the ehoma will range from the multifarious cultural events in people's life cycles, ceremonies, rites and rituals to cultural roles that include enhancing and/or facilitating specific ceremonies, as well as being symbolic representations in the socio-cultural positions of power. These non musical roles of the ehoma will be discussed in three basic categories including the communicative, the ceremonial and the symbolic.

    The presentation will in conclusion examine the argument that owing to the central role they play and the extent to which they are used in the tradition of the Baganda more than any other instrument, the ehoma should justifiably be metaphorically referred to as the 'heart' of the Ganda culture.

    The Palmer Orpharion - A re-evaluation

    Darryl Martin,
    University of Edinburgh

    The Francis Palmer Orpharion, now housed in the Musikhistoriska Museum, Copenhagen, is the only dated extant speciman, and one of only three known to survive. Tuned as a lute, it was built in 1617, during a period where lute music composition was at its high point in England, and is the only surviving English-made instrument designed for that repertoire. This particular instrument has been the used as the basis for almost all modern orpharion reproductions, and has been the subject of some controversy concerning its original state. This paper will discuss the instrument in light of a detailed personal examination of the instrument made by the author in 2002.

    The instrument will also be discussed in relation to stringing and pitch standards that have been proposed by various modern authors. The similarity between the surviving Palmer instrument and the dimensions of an instrument measured by James Talbot in c. 1690 show that similar instruments were used throughout the seventeenth century in England, and the basic similarity between the Palmer and the orpharion illustrated by Praetorius will also be discussed. In particular, the paper will consider the stringing materials used for the top string and the bass strings with particular reference to string and string-making technologies.

    Panel session: the Timpani

    Jeremy Montagu, Edmund Bowles and Harrison Powley

    This one-hour session will consist of presentations by Edmund Bowles and Harrison Powley, with contributions by Jeremy Montagu, who will also chair the session.

    Altered Timpani Parts and Plastic Heads: Ad libitum and Noisy Playing Gone Wild ?

    Edmund A. Bowles

    Perhaps the most important - and controversial - change that has been taking place concerning the timpani over the last fifty years or so has to do with the perceived role of this instrument in the orchestra. There seems to have been a fundamental shift, particularly in America, away from the concept of the timpani as an ensemble instrument, playing faithfully from the score as published, to the idea of it functioning in a solo capacity. Indeed, many players take it upon themselves to "edit" their parts with impunity, thereby throwing authenticity to the winds. This can range from merely altering pitches to correct dissonances to adding extra drums for a third or even a fourth note to rapid pedaling in order to produce a series of chromaticisms. And whereas in the past drums blended in with the overall orchestral texture, now they are usually in the forefront, their sounds more forward, louder, more "percussive".

    This brings up a number of important issues, such as the role of the conductor (who may either be encouraging his timpanist in these matters or simply doesn't care), the implied freedom of the timpanist to interpolate (why not the strings or winds ?) in the face of an orchestra otherwise playing from the score, the relative importance of trying to faithfully realize the composer's intentions (performance practice), and the whole question of whether the timpani are ensemble or solo instruments.

    New Discoveries on the Performance of Late 18th-Century Music for Multiple Timpani

    Harrison Powley,
    Music School of Music
    Brigham Young University

    Since the end of the 19th century scholars have known a few orchestral compositions using more than the customary two to four timpani, but recent archival research reveals that the late 18th- and early 19th-century solo concerto repertory for the timpani is larger than previously recognized or expected. Composers used the timpani in much more intricate and complicated ways than have been generally supposed and some timpanists developed virtuosic techniques. Normally, in the 18th century music required no more than two timpani since most noblemen, who had military music, had but one pair of drums that they could move inside to play with the court orchestra. Nevertheless, in certain courts and when there was a virtuoso present composers sometimes wrote for more than two timpani, in one instance for as many as sixteen. In the works for multiple timpani, the timpani reinforce the entire bass line or play the melody, often doubling the high strings or woodwinds.

    Jean George Kastner in his Méthode de timballes (ca.&nbps;1845) recounts that at the turn of the 19th century the first timpanist in Berlin "executed a concerto for timpani that used ten different drums and pitches" and that "he ran from one drum to another on a kind of gallery, threw his sticks in the air, and made the most extraordinary movements without his playing suffering." Kastner also mentions that the concerto used eight trumpets and orchestra to accompany him. On the placement of the drums, Central European timpanists, then and now, prefer to have the larger drums on the right side. In performing the multiple timpani works, performers may arrange the drums in a semicircular or even circular array. My research reveals another and possibly more practical approach to drum placement.

    Of the virtuoso timpanists identified in the late 18th century, the most important as a composer of several works, perhaps written for himself as soloist, is Georg Druschetzky (1745-1819). The bulk of his music is unedited in the Hungarian National Library in Budapest. Characteristic of Druschetzky's approach to writing for multiple timpani is his consistent use of the timpani as primarily a melodic instrument, often doubling the woodwinds or strings. To illustrate his style we will focus our attention on his Partita and Concerto, both using six timpani. Druschetzky probably wrote these works in the last few years of the 18th century. While in Budapest I found a diagram of a six-drum arrangement for the Partita on the back of the timpani part, this had not been previously microfilmed. The six drums are to be arranged as three pairs tuned to perfect fourths, the larger of each pair to the players right, G-c, A-d, and B-e. In the timpani part to the Concerto, are stickings written by an earlier timpanist, perhaps Druschetzky himself. These stickings reveal this unusual paired arrangement of the timpani. Also preserved with the materials for the Concerto are two versions of a cadenza appropriate to the first movement.

    This paper discusses these performance issues and will be illustrated with slides and recorded musical examples.

    Endingidi: An African Instrument with a Lasting Impact

    Elizabeth Ndagire
    Kampala, Uganda

    Endingidi is a term used to refer to one of the traditional chordophones of the Baganda, a people that live in the East African nation of Uganda. After briefly discussing the construction materials used to set up its unique structural design as an artifact including a single string, a wooden tube open on one end but closed on the other with a membrane of an animal skin, then a neck decorated with a tassel from a goat skin, this paper will briefly discuss the playing techniques and musical roles as well as the functions of the three different types of endingindi including ekitamba, olutamba and akatamba.

    The paper will then highlight, examine and discuss the role of endingidi in the specific contextual and cultural traditional setting for which it is used by the Baganda as a folk instrument assigned in their culture. These contexts which include entertainment, social, political and ethical commentaries as well as traditional taboos will be briefly examined in the cultural setting and the extent to which they cement the cultural roots and provide catharsis to both the players and listeners.

    Finally, using my personal experience with endingidi, I will conclude my paper presentation by examining the extent to which all the above elements that will have been discussed highlight the power of the endingidi in creating a lasting musical and cultural impact to both the players and listeners in the musical culture of the Baganda (people in Uganda.

    Culliford & Co: Keyboard Instrument Makers in Georgian London

    Jenny Nex
    Royal College of Music,
    London

    Thomas Culliford (c.1747-c.1820) is best known as a maker of harpsichords and pianos who supplied instruments to Longman & Broderip in late 18th-century London. However, archival sources show that Culliford was an important maker in his own right, working in partnership with makers such as John Geib and William Rolfe. Of particular interest is his relationship with his son-in-law Charles Barrow, with whom he worked until their bankruptcy in 1798. Culliford retired from the London scene and ended his days in Hampshire with his wife Mary; Barrow went on to work for the Navy Pay Office, from where he absconded with Navy funds before spending the last years of his life as a church organist on the Isle of Man. Using court cases, bankruptcy records, insurance records and parish archives, this paper will illuminate the lives of Thomas Culliford and Charles Barrow and trace their activities as instrument builders in Georgian London.

    The Tiorbino: an Instrument Built by Harpsichord Makers: Supporting Data and Documents

    Francesco Nocerino
    Naples, Italy

    Hitherto the term tiorbino has generally been understood to mean a small octave tiorba: in other words, an instrument similar to the theorbo, but smaller and hence higher-pitched. A second possible meaning could be that it refers to a harpsichord stop. Now, in support of a third meaning, which identifies the "tiorbino" as a keyboard instrument, documents are examined relating not only to known harpsichord makers, like Onofrio Guarracino, Antonio Sabbatino and Gaetano Carotenuto, but also to other builders that are either largely or completely unknown, like Salvatore Sanchez, Giuseppe de Simone and Gaetano Baldassarro, all active in Naples between the second half of the seventeenth and the early eighteenth centuries.

    Salient characteristic of the "tiorbino" to emerge from the documents examined include an outer case, an ivory keyboard, the presence of two stops, a fully chromatic bass octave down to c,, a stand and the difficulty of tuning these instruments. Finally, the argument that the tiorbino is a keyboard instrument is further supported by Filippo Bonanni's engraving in the Galleria Armonica in the Palazzo Verospi, with the accompanying description by Michele Todini.

    Analysis of the Origins of a Large Franco-"Flemish" Double-Manual Harpsichord: Would a Ruckers by any Other Name Sound as Sweet ?

    Grant O'Brien
    University of Edinburgh

    An extremely fine 5-octave double-manual harpsichord, on temporary deposit in the Russell Collection, has recently been entrusted to me for examination and study. The general appearance of the instrument has all of the usual characteristics of a late eighteenth-century French instrument. Indeed, at the time of a restoration made in 1971 it was found to bear the signature of Jacques Barberini who worked in Paris in the second half of the eighteenth century. It has a French carved and gilt stand, case paintings in the style of François Boucher, a painted soundboard, etc. It also has a Ruckers soundboard rosette with the initials "HR" and this appears to be genuine. However the rosette is too small to fit into the hole into which it has been placed suggesting that the instrument was not originally a product of the Ruckers workshops. A careful analysis of the original pinning of the bridges and the 4-ft hitchpin rail indicates, however, that the instrument originally had a compass of C/E to f3 and that there were doubled strings for the eb/g# notes like those of a Ruckers double-manual "transposing" harpsichord.

    This paper attempts to analyse and to understand the original state of this harpsichord and, using a statistical analysis of the original string spacings in conjunction with the unit of measurement used to design these, to determine its country of origin.

    The Organized Piano (piano-claviórgano) in Spain: a Preliminary View

    Beryl Kenyon de Pascual,
    Madrid

    Claviorgana, i.e. all keyboard instruments that combine strings and organ pipes, have a long history in Spain that can be traced back to the 15th century. The earliest instruments were owned by kings, church dignitaries and the nobility, which suggests that they were not especially intended for use in church. In the 16th, 17th, 18th and early 19th centuries, however, we find references to claviorgana in cathedral chapter records.

    The advent of the square piano from abroad during the 1770s and later imports of organized pianos gave an impulse to the production of such instruments in Spain. Claviorgana were again aimed primarily at amateur and lay musicians. Contemporary newspapers are a useful source of information and a survey of the advertisements placed in Madrid newspapers during the last quarter of the 18th century has yielded quite a detailed picture of the types of organized pianos available then. Most of the makers in Madrid seem to have been organ-builders, both Spanish and foreign, while imported models came mainly from England.

    Six organized pianos have been located in Spain: (1) a square instrument with a single manual by Buntebart and Sievers; (2) a two-manual square model made by Francisco Flórez; (3) a one-manual square instrument with Longman and Broderip's label; (4-5) two by the Swiss-German organ- and piano-builders Franz Otter and Johann Kyburz, one of which is a large square instrument with two manuals, seven organ registers and the piano element as well as a pedal for military-music effects; and (6) a grand piano in the German or Viennese-style from the early 19th century with a register of free reeds.

    There is evidence that an upright piano with organ pipes was made in the second half of the 19th century but it does not appear to have survived.

    Historical Bassoon Reed Making: Discovering the Missing Pieces

    David Rachor
    University of Northern Iowa, Cedar Falls, Iowa

    Most bassoonists would agree that the reed, the tone generator of the bassoon, fundamentally affects tone color, intonation, pitch and dynamics. If one intention of the period instrument movement is to recreate the overall playing characteristics of original instruments, then a great deal of attention must be paid to the reed since these charactistics are largely determined by it.

    In order to recreate the original sound of bassoons, reeds ideally should be made using the same methods and materials used when the instrument itself was made. However, problems abound for us interested in making reeds based on historical principles. Constructing a bassoon reed using 18th and early 19th century sources, one quickly discovers that many very important details are missing, even though several sources provide a fairly detailed outline of the methods used. Following instructions given in the most detailed sources, namely Cungier, Ozi, Froelich and Almenraeder, one cannot make a playable reed. [By playable reed I mean a reed that a professional period bassoonist could use in a professional period orchestra.] Even when one compiles information given collectively in all four sources, one cannot make a playable reed. Many of these missing details pertain to the thickness of the gouge and the general scrape of the reed blades, but there are numerous other missing links as well.

    An important element in making historical bassoon reeds is the cane that one uses to construct the reed. It is my opinion that one cannot make a historical bassoon reed using the same cane that one uses to make modern reeds. If one uses the softer cane that I believe typically was found in the 18th and early 19th centuries, one can make a playable reed using historical reed-making techniques.

    In the paper, I will outline the necessary steps given in 18th and 19th century sources to make a reed for a period bassoon. I will discuss the missing details of reed construction, specifically as it pertains to dimensions of gouge and scrape, that I have discovered necessary to make a playable bassoon reed, and will discuss my recent research into cane hardness conducted at the United States National Forestry Laboratory.

    19th-Century Amateur Music Societies and the Changes of Instrument Construction : their Evolution Caught Between Passivity and Progress

    Jean-Yves Rauline
    Univerité de Rouen, France

    Musical societies, whose numbers increased considerably in France at the end of the Second Empire, were particularly concerned by the developments in instrument construction, especially wind instruments. Many manufacturers, such as Besson and Sax, were aware of the size of the market represented by non-military music and encouraged people to replace their old or obsolete instruments by new models. National leaders of the wind band movement did the same and even proposed typical groups adapted to the players of the time. Being under pressure, it would have been logical to assume that instrumental groups would have been at the forefront of such progress and would have adopted the latest improvements invented and patented by the manufacturers.

    The example of the Upper Normandy societies proves the opposite, and on the contrary, a much more pragmatic attitude was the rule: because of lack of finance, instruments were usually replaced one at a time often by second hand models; the most efficient systems for wood-wind were not adopted for reasons of tradition and because the technique required was far below the level of the great virtuosos; on the other hand, improvements and new brass instruments developed by Adolphe Sax-saxhorns and saxo-trombas, but also saxophones-had enormous success because of their quality, regularity of timbre and because they were easy to play. However, to imagine that the Upper Normandy wind band movement was too conservative, would be incorrect: there was certainly some hesitation in adopting the official diapason, but the invention of the "cécilium" is evidence that a local conductor could be ingenious when it came to making up for lack of players...

    British Innovations in Clarinet Design, ca. 1775-1830

    Albert R. Rice
    Fiske Museum,
    Claremont, California

    Of early clarinets, those made in Britain during the eighteenth and early nineteenth-century are the most commonly preserved and widely dispersed geographically. This is a result of the strong British economy and trade throughout the Empire. This paper discusses several British innovations that made their clarinets popular — innovations subsequently widely adopted, including a sixth key for an A-B trill; the use of metal lined barrels; metal bushings in tone holes; metal swivel key heads; a combined right-hand joint and stock section; the addition of keys around 1800; cork tenons; and overlapping touch pieces. Innovations developed by continental makers adopted by British makers are also noted. Makers discussed include George Miller, Thomas Collier, John Hale, James Wood, Thomas Key, Tebaldo Monzani, William Milhouse, Goulding & Company, Wood & Son, Goulding & D'’Almaine, William Gutteridge, and Thomas Prowse.

    The Harpsichord by Lodewyk Theewes, London, 1579: its History and Significance

    Malcolm Rose
    Lewes, East Sussex, U.K.

    Since writing my article on the Theewes claviorgan of 1579 in the Victoria & Albert Museum, London (Galpin Society Journal LV, 2002), I have made some progress in investigating the background of Theewes himself, and the circumstances in which he made this outstanding instrument. This talk will be a report on these further developments.

    After a brief description of the instrument, I will consider what kind of instruments Theewes may have seen and made during his apprenticeship in the Netherlands, and how these experiences may have influenced the design of the London harpsichord. I will then explain the circumstances of Theewes's move to London with his family, and trace some details of his life there from church and state records. Lastly, I will show who the original owner of the claviorgan was, where he lived, and how close a friendship he enjoyed with some of the leading musicians of the time. It becomes clear that some of the greatest virginalists must have known the claviorgan at first hand, making it of even greater significance than we have realised before.

    New and Innovated Musical Instruments and the Birth of the Patent System in 19th-century Italy

    Gabriele Rossi-Rognoni,
    Galleria dell'Accademia, Museo degli Strumenti Musicali
    Florence, Italy

    The patent system was introduced in the Italian States during the first half of the 19th century, a short time after the abolition of the guild system. After 1859 a common system was gradually extended to the whole peninsula and over 300 musical instruments were patented during the second half of the century. At the same time, since Italian patents (following the French legal model) did not guarantee either the quality or novelty of the new products, a net of industrial exhibitions was established in the various States, where scientific Academies strictly connected to the government granted medals to the most interesting innovations. The parallel study of patents and exhibitions offers valuable information about the way new technologies and production systems were introduced in the production of musical instruments and about their success and characteristics, also when few or no exemplars survive today. It is also a major repository of information about what, when and from where foreign innovations have been imported.

    The Art Case Piano Stands as an Icon at the Crossroads of Western Culture

    Maximiliaan Rutten
    Miami, Florida, U.S.A.

    The traditions of the richly decorated harpsichords in the 16th and 17th century, and, more recently, of elaborately painted organ panels, have been much explored in the academic world. It is therefore curious, that the history of the art case piano has only received incidental attention by scholars.

    The significance of the art case piano can hardly be underestimated. Art case pianos stand at a crossroads of art history: they combine every aspect of the fine arts, ranging from oil painting and furniture design, to the fine crafts of 24-karat bronze gilding techniques and the lost art of marquetry inlay patterns. They were often built for royal families and aristocracy and often designed by famous designers, furniture makers and architects. They were often owned for their social status, or simply as trophies of personal success. They are now celebrated as icons for Western culture and they have become symbols of individual expression.

    Following shortly after the 300th anniversary of Cristofori's invention of the modern piano, this lecture will explore 3 centuries of history of the art case piano, their social and economic significance, the techniques used to decorate them, their symbolism and their value as cultural icons of Western civilization. The lecture will tie a link to the year 2003, in which three of the most prominent art case piano builders, Steinway, Bechstein and Bluthner, will celebrates their 150th anniversary. Other manufacturers, like Broadwood, Erard, Pleyel, Gaveau, will also have their place in this lecture.

    Recent Reconstructions of the Geigenwerk

    Carolyn W. Simons

    From 1575 to the present, almost 100 instrument makers have attempted to combine the versatility of keyboard playing with the continuous sound of bowed strings. Museums throughout Europe and in Russia house numerous examples of these fascinating but little-known bowed string keyboards. In this paper three working instruments, each an exemplar of its type, will be explored by means of photographs and recordings and available patent information. Two of the instruments have been restored in the last decade; the third is a modern reconstruction of the original German model, the Geigenwerk.

    The first known bowed keyboard, the Geigenwerk, was invented by Hans Haiden of Nuremburg in 1575. In an attempt to produce a keyboard instrument with the ability to create dynamic expression along with an indefinitely sustained pitch, Haiden designed the Geigenwerk, a keyboard instrument whose strings were bowed by a moving band of horsehair or by turning resined wheels. In the last 20 years Haiden's instrument has been reconstructed from the woodcuts in Michael Praetorius's Syntagma Musica by makers in Germany, Japan, and the United States. The Geigenwerk to be discussed in this paper was built in 1985 by Kurt Reichmann of Frankfurt and is located in Lissberg, Germany. A privately-owned 2002 Geigenwerk by Akio Obuchi of Japan will also be referred to and heard.

    Another bowed-keyboard model is the mid-nineteenth-century piano quatuor by Baudet of Paris. Based on the principle of transferred vibrations, the piano quatuor uses a revolving cylinder to rub fiber appendages attached to the strings. The vibrations excited in these fibers transfer to the strings, causing them to sound. Baudet's advertisement claims that the piano quatuor can produce all the effects of a string quartet. Extant examples may be found in numerous European museums; this paper will deal with the one belonging to the Württemburgisches Landesmuseum in Stuttgart, restored in the last decade.

    The Technisches Museum in Vienna houses the third instrument to be presented, a recently renovated Streichklavier built by the Hofmann and Czerny piano firm in 1915. Similar in principle to the Geigenwerk, but unique in application, it uses revolving leather bands to excite the strings. In its impressive black-lacquered grand piano case, the Streichklavier was an exhibition instrument, intended to tour major European cities.

    These three instruments represent some of the most successful attempts to achieve the continuous sound of bowed strings and dynamic flexibility from the relative ease and polyphonic capabilities of the keyboard. The inherent acoustical challenges of this combination are great; these examples will demonstrate different ways builders rose to those challenges and produced unique contributions to the musical scene.

    Pedal Effects on an Early English Piano: Lecture-Demonstration

    Susanne Skyrm,
    Vermillion

    Several types of special effects pedals was added to pianos by manufacturers in the early part of the 19th century. These were intended to attract the growing market of middle class music consumers, who wanted to own and play an instrument, but didn't necessarily know much about music. Manufacturers rightly figured the more sounds available, the more pianos one could sell. Although most extra pedals were intended to create percussive effects, there were a few that changed the timbre and volume of the actual piano sound. These allowed the pianist more control over subtle gradations in volume and nuance to create sounds that are impossible to reproduce on today's modern pianos.

    The percussive pedal trend never quite caught on among piano builders in the United Kingdom (perhaps due to the innate good taste of the populace), but some pianos did possess pedal mechanisms that allowed the pianist to manipulate volume and timbre. The grand piano by Thomas Loud (probably made sometime between 1805 and 1810) in the Russell Collection of Early Keyboards possesses several such devices. The left pedal, which normally reduces the number of strings struck by each hammer from three to two, can be depressed even further when a latch is lifted on the treble keyblock, reducing the sound to a true una corda. The right pedal has two parts side-by-side which are normally pressed together but can be pressed separately enabling the player to raise the treble or bass dampers selectively. The effects made possible on this instrument range from a harp-like timbre to music box effects to tones that are barely audible.

    In this lecture-demonstration I will give a brief explanation of special effects pedals in general, explain the mechanism on the Loud piano and play representative pieces that will highlight the unique sound effects possible on it. I will perform music by composers from both the British Isles and the Continent who were working in the transitional period between the late Classic and early Romantic eras and who were familiar with the sound possibilities on the grand pianos being manufactured at the time. Such composers may include, but will not be limited to, Jan Dussek, John Field, Muzio Clementi, Henri Herz, Jan Vorísek, and Ludwig van Beethoven.

    Nomen est Omen: the French Horn in England during the Nineteenth and First Half of the Twentieth Century

    E. Bradley Strauchen,
    The Horniman Museum & Gardens
    London

    The use of the term "French horn" to describe the orchestral horn is often a point of contention among scholars and players of the instrument, but it becomes arguably appropriate when applied to the horn in England during the end of the nineteenth and first half of the twentieth century. The use of narrow bore piston-valve horns by the Brain family - whose name is synonymous with this, the most distinctive period in British horn playing - was the culmination of the English preference for the French-style horn and the clear, light sound attributed to it.

    This was a marked departure from the horn playing landscape in England in the first decades of the nineteenth century. A cursory survey of horn players and their instruments during these years reveals a strong Austro-German presence. Examination of surviving horns by contemporary English makers yields many examples with the wide, sharply flared bore profile characteristic of Austro-German instruments. But while the valve horn gained a foothold in Germany after its first appearance c.1814, the English followed the French in eschewing this change. The horn virtuoso Giovanni Puzzi, who dominated horn playing in England from 1817 to c.1855, was a firm adherent of the natural horn and played French-built Raoux instruments throughout his career. The development of distribution networks for Raoux horns during the second half of the nineteenth century heightened the accessibility and popularity of these instruments, and the sound of the French-style horn became a characteristic of English orchestras. The original horn section of the London Symphony Orchestra, formed in 1904 and referred to as "God's own quartet", is a notable example. The section, which included A.E. Brain, was lead by Dresden trained Adolf Borsdorf, who played a modified L.-J. Raoux horn that previously belonged to Puzzi.

    This paper will explore the gradual shift of English preference from German to French-style horns and sound quality through consideration of instruments, players and performance practice during the nineteenth and early twentieth century. It will refer to a number of horns in collections that delegates will have an opportunity to view during the AMIS and Galpin Society meeting.

    Tracing a Curious Bassoon from Lund to Neukirchen

    Benjamin Vogel,
    Lund, Sweden

    The Museum of Cultural History (Kulturhistoriska Museet) in Lund possesses a strange bassoon with two bells: one of brass, wide open, and one almost in standard form but with a muting device. The instrument has a confusion of keys of different shapes and with different saddles. It would appear to have been made at the turn of the 18th century, but it was difficult to begin to determine by whom and where, as there is no visible signature. Furthermore, the inventory number increases confusion, as it indicates an Irish bagpipe in the museum's inventory. Thorough examination and research have made it possible to find a trace of signature, and to match it with a particular maker. Further research has improved our knowledge about the original form of the instrument and its various stages of alteration.

    A.J. Hipkins (1826-1903): a Centenary Perspective

    Elizabeth Wells,
    Royal College of Music Museum of Instruments
    London

    The pioneering work on historic musical instruments of Alfred James Hipkins as researcher, performer, lecturer and author was respected in his lifetime and has been acknowledged ever since. He is known today chiefly through two of his publications, Musical Instruments, Historic, Rare and Unique, illustrated by William Gibb (1888), and A Description and History of the Piano-forte and of the older keyboard stringed instruments (1896), as well as his many articles in the Encyclopaedia Britannica and Grove's Dictionary of Music and Musicians. Drawing on unpublished documents, this paper will review the breadth of his achievement and focus on his work for loan exhibitions (the International Inventions Exhibition in London, 1885, and International Exhibition of Music and Theatre in Vienna, 1892) and his role in establishing the collections of instruments, intended as a permanent national resource, at the Royal College of Music in 1894. Hipkins was Honorary Curator of its General Museum until his death in 1903 and also wrote the Catalogue for its Donaldson Museum in 1894.

    To be illustrated with slides and a recording of the Kirkman harpsichord that was formerly owned by Carl Engel and then by Hipkins.

    Woodwind Instruments of Boosey & Company

    Kelly J. White,
    Albuquerque, New Mexico, U.S.A.

    The London music publishing and instrument manufacturing firm of Boosey & Company started making woodwind instruments in the 1850s. After the merger with Hawkes & Son in 1930, instruments continued to be made under the Boosey & Co. name for a few years. The firm is credited with being the first to produce the Pratten system flute and the Clinton system clarinet. The New Langwill Index records that Eugene Albert (of Albert system clarinet fame) visited the Boosey factory as a clarinet advisor in 1880.

    Despite the leading role of Boosey & Co in British wind instrument manufacture, there has been no systematic study until now of the firm's archives relating to woodwinds. These documents record in detail the instruments they produced and in many cases to whom they were sold. This paper surveys the operating practices of a major woodwind manufacturer and how they responded to changing musical demands in the period 1857-1931.

    The Köhler Family History: A Re-assessment

    Lance Whitehead,
    Royal College of Music,
    London

    Much of the current literature concerning the Köhler family history appears to be ultimately derived from the first edition of Grove's Dictionary of Music and Musicians (1879) and contemporary Trades Directories. Although many of John Köhler I's biographical details are difficult to verify, a comprehensive survey of Trades Directories, Rate Books, Census Returns and Parish Registers for the period 1780-1910 has shown that a re-assessment of this important military wind-instrument making dynasty is well overdue. As well as providing the name of Augustus Charles's successor, for instance, this study will attempt to clarify the confusion surrounding John II and John Augustus Köhler. Moreover, by including a revised list of addresses and dates for the family, this should prove a useful addition for those involved in the dating of Köhler instruments.


    This page updated: 12.8.03; re-published 14.2.13